There’s no better way to start your day in sunny, beautiful Siesta Key than with a delicious breakfast, and there’s no shortage of great spots to try just minutes from your Siesta Key Dreams vacation rental.
Whether you just want to grab a coffee and a bagel before hitting the beach or indulge in a hearty plate of eggs benedict or Belgian waffles before a day of sightseeing and shopping — we have you covered.
Here are 7 of the best breakfast spots in Siesta Key to bookmark for your trip to this one-of-a-kind island paradise!
1. Sun Garden Cafe
- 210 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key, FL
- sungardencafe.com
- $$$
- Breezy breakfast spot with outdoor seating and mouth-watering specialties like cookie butter French toast and Cajun benedict
Rated #1 for best breakfast in Siesta Key on Tripadvisor and Yelp, Sun Garden Cafe is a can’t miss when visiting the island.
From their homemade pecan sticky buns and fresh fruit smoothies to indulgent specialties like the Cajun-style eggs benedict and cookie butter stuffed French toast, everything on the menu at Sun Garden is pure perfection! Of course, you’ll also find all your classic breakfast favorites on the menu, like omelets, pancakes, breakfast sandwiches, and so much more.
Sun Garden prides itself on using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, including eggs and produce from local farms and seafood right from the Gulf, so everything on your plate is as fresh as can be.
2. Toasted Mango Cafe
- 6621 Midnight Pass Rd, Siesta Key, FL
- toastedmangocafe.com
- $$
- Tropical breakfast cafe serving island-style eats like mango waffles and breakfast banana splits
With island vibes and a menu of tasty classics with a tropical twist, Toasted Mango Cafe is a must-stop for breakfast or brunch.
While you’ll find all the traditional breakfast dishes like eggs and French toast, the specialty dishes are where the Toasted Mango Cafe really shines. The Award-Winning Toasted Mango Waffle lives up to the hype with fresh mango, toasted coconut, and whipped cream for a truly tropical treat. And the breakfast banana split with fresh fruit, yogurt, and granola is another must-try.
If you’re looking for a lighter bite, Toasted Mango Cafe also serves up egg-white omelets, avocado toasts, oatmeal, and other lighter fare to accommodate all tastes – they even have gluten-free options!
3. Village Cafe
- 5133 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL
- villagecafeonsiesta.com
- $$
- Buzzing breakfast cafe loved by the locals for its tasty classics, like eggs benedict, and creative specialties, like cinnamon roll French toast
A family-run favorite since 1995, Village Cafe serves up some of the best breakfasts in Siesta Key. A sentiment you’ll notice as soon as you walk through the door; this place is always packed!
You’ll find all the classics like pancakes, omelets, and eggs benedict, plus some tasty specialty dishes like cinnamon roll French toast, sweet potato pancakes, and brisket breakfast skillets. And, of course, there’s always fresh coffee brewing, morning juices, and even Bloody Marys and mimosas if you’re in the mood.
If you’re dining with the family, the Mickey Mouse pancakes are always a hit with the little ones. There’s something tasty for everyone to start their day with at Village Cafe.
4. Bonjour French Cafe
- 5124 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL
- facebook.com/bonjourfrenchcafe/
- $$
- French cafe serving up decadent classics like quiche, crepes, omelets, and croissants
A taste of France right in the heart of Siesta Key, Bonjour French Cafe serves up decadent French classics like goat cheese omelets, sweet or savory crepes, cheesy quiches, and freshly baked croissants.
Of course, no French breakfast is complete without a cappuccino or espresso, and you’ll find those on the menu too, as well as regular coffee, juices, mimosas, and more.
Bonjour French Cafe also cooks up some American-style classics like biscuits and gravy, Western omelets, and avocado toast. So whether you’re feeling like a French or American breakfast, Bonjour has you covered.
5. Mojo Risin’ Coffee Company
- 521 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL
- mojorisincoffee.com
- $
- Hip coffee shop with beachy vibes and fresh baked goods
If you’re more of a coffee and pastry kind of breakfast person or just want a quick bite on your way to the beach, Mojo Risin’ Coffee Company has your number!
Enjoy gourmet coffee drinks in fun island flavors like Siesta coconut and monkey mocha, along with freshly baked muffins, banana bread, bagels, and other baked goods.
And if you’re looking for a lighter bite, Mojo Risin’ also whips up fresh smoothies, juices, acai bowls, vegan muffins, and much more. There’s something for everyone on the menu at Mojo.
6. Another Broken Egg Cafe
- 140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL
- anotherbrokenegg.com
- $$
- Cozy, casual breakfast spot serving up familiar favorites like eggs, pancakes, and waffles
A favorite among locals and visitors alike, Another Broken Egg Cafe serves up all your breakfast favorites like eggs, buttermilk pancakes, biscuits and gravy, and much more.
In addition to all the classics, you’ll also find breakfast specialties like strawberry pound cake French toast and cookie dough Belgian waffles, for a decadent treat.
There’s always fresh-brewed coffee flowing, fresh juices, and even breakfast cocktails like Bloody Mary’s if you’re feeling festive!
7. Captain Curt’s Coffee Shop
- 1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Siesta Key, FL
- captaincurts.com
- $
- Casual coffee shop serving up iced coffee treats, baked goods, and breakfast sandwiches
Part of Captain Curt’s Village, featuring restaurants, bars, shops, and entertainment, Captain Curt’s Coffee Shop is a great place to stop for a quick breakfast when strolling the shops or getting ready to head out on your bike or kayak rental next door.
You’ll find all your favorite coffee drinks, including cold brew, blended frappes, and iced mochas, plus smoothies, pastries, breakfast sandwiches, and other quick breakfast bites.
If you’re not in a hurry, enjoy your coffee and breakfast under Captain Curt’s breezy Tiki hut or outside, overlooking the water, for a relaxing way to start your day.
Which Siesta Key Breakfast Spot Will You Try First?
Whether you’re on a weekend getaway or visiting for the whole week, there are enough great breakfast spots in Siesta Key to try a new one each day. And if you’re in the mood to venture off the island, you’ll find even more great options just across the bridge in Sarasota.
Ready to plan your perfect Siesta Key vacation? Book your stay with Siesta Key Dreams Vacation Rentals for the ultimate tropical escape. Enjoy fully furnished vacation homes, cozy condos, beachy bungalows, and more — all with premium amenities like private pools, docks, and BBQ grills.
And the best part is, you’re always just minutes, and in some cases even steps, from all the best things to do in Siesta Key.